Cardstock Color List
New to consigning? Start with our Consignor Info - 10-Step Guide to see the whole process from registration to Pickup.
Questions? Join our Consignor Facebook Group and post your consigning and tagging questions there!
Strategy & Privileges
- White Tags (Donate): Use white cardstock to donate unsold items. This allows you to skip Pickup and often shop earlier! Note: White tag items are donated before Pickup — but any items accepted at the EverythingELSE Sale roll over automatically to the EverythingELSE Sale rather than being donated.
- Color Tags (Pickup or Rollover): Use your assigned color for items you want returned if they don't sell, or to have them automatically roll over to the EverythingELSE Sale. You can use a mix of white & color tags if you want to donate some & Pickup/rollover some.
- Supplies: Find your paper and other supplies easily at our Amazon Shop.
Cardstock & Tagging Rules
- Weight Requirements: Use 65-67 lb cardstock. Regular paper is too flimsy; 100 lb paper often jams printers.
- Discounting (75% Off): We highly recommend the 75% discount option at KE.
- Printer Failures: If color printing fails or you do not have a color printer, print in black & white, but you must manually circle the price: RED Pen for "No Discount" or GREEN Pen for "50% Discount."
- 3000's Color: If available, use LIGHT PINK instead of red for the 3000's code. It scans more easily!
- Tag Durability: Add tape over the tag corner before punching the hole. Use two layers for shoe tags. Do not cover the QR code.